SF Skyline shown with permission by photographer Lane Hartwell 

DRM-Free Music: Putting My Money Where My Mouth Is

DRMfree.org Since before Napster1.0 was closed down I verbally shared with anyone that would listen what the future of music sales should be. When I buy the license to own a song, that license should not be limited to the format I bought the song in. Whether LP, cassette, CD and then later digital-rights management (DRM) digital download, I should own the right to a copy of that song ad infinitum. Considering how cheap digital download is for the publisher versus printed on a CD or other device, what I wanted (and still want) is a lifelong license with that song so I could download it again and again, as I had bought the right to the song, not just the song on that one format I bought it in. You buy the song and it’s your to do whatever you want with.

For the last two years I have gone back to buying CDs as they almost never have DRM controls on them and then I could burn it to my computer, Molly’s computer and then we could move it around to our music players, or play in the CD player in the car or house. This has been much more convenient then buying online and only being able to listen to it on devices approved by the seller or having to rip it and reinstall it over the purchased copy. I hated how iTunes would know I had bought DRM songs, but not allow me to re-download them after my harddrive crashed. Other sites offered DRM-free downloads, but had obscure libraries to chose from.

We’re still at my desired relationship of lifelong download rights, but the ability to buy downloads of popular songs that you can play and store on any digital device is here. iTunes and Amazon have both begun offering as much of their catalogs as the publishers will offer for slightly more, but without any encryption or listening-control software.

I just purchased my first DRM-free tracks from iTunes. The New Beatie Boys instrumental album and the new LCD Soundsystem. Kudos to their publishing team that chose to step forward into this brave new world of actually trusting their customers instead of treating them like a thief-in-waiting. Clever foks they are, they even get to charge a premium for getting DRM-free but it’s worth it. iTunes even offers an option to buy upgrades (their words not mine) your DRM downloads to DRM-free version I would have liked to buy the new Arctic Monkeys, but I’ll have to buy the CD for that. From here on out, however, any DRM-free album I can buy I will simply to show the publishers that this is where there customers are and thanks for trusting us.

DRMfree.org is a clever in-development service that will direct you to where you can find DRM-free downloads of the bands of your choice. The image I use above is from their site.

3 Responses to “DRM-Free Music: Putting My Money Where My Mouth Is” »»

  1. Comment by Tony Guntharp | 07/02/07 at 8:35 pm

    Ted,
    Actually you can re-download iTunes purchases although it’s currently a one time deal.

    http://thecontent.wordpress.com/2006/05/24/itunes-lets-people-re-download-all-your-music-once/

  2. Comment by Swerbo | 07/03/07 at 11:05 am

    I agree bigtime with your mantra on the re-downloading, right to the music for life thing. But I would add one more thing that’s still keeping me personally away from iTunes, and that is the format. Even if it is DRM-free, I want to use a format that is universally supported — and right now the choice is simple, MP3.

    Now sure, their codec is arguably slightly better on the quality/size front, and maybe ogg is too, but let’s face it, memory and hard disk space is cheap these days, and that advantage is easily fixed by cranking up the bitrate on your MP3 encodes, so whatever. It’s way more important that I know for a fact that the music files can play in any and every device out there.

    Now, also, if you ask me, for those kind of prices on the DRM-free side of the world, I think you should actually get lossless files personally. I mean if I buy it on CD, I get the 16-bit WAV files, which I can then encode to any format I want, and then again, maybe I’d prefer to “rockbox” my ipod, losslessly encode the wavs to FLAC, and play the hi-fi 16-bit files themselves on my ipod?

    Seems to me we aren’t quite there yet, CD is still the option of choice, and the prices are still too high. But at least it’s moving in the right direction now…

  3. Comment by Ted Rheingold | 07/03/07 at 2:35 pm

    Swerbo you’re stud. What you said!

    And Tony, I’m gonna try and do some re-downloading, but I have a feeling the offer will not apply to me and my lost harddrive

Leave a Reply »»